Crime and Punishment by R.K.Narayan

 Crime and Punishment by R.K.Narayan

💠 Hello learners. I'm a student. I'm writing this blog as a part of thinking activity. This task is assign by Megha Ma'am. This task is based on short story Crime and Punishment by R.K. Narayan. 

"Crime and Punishment" is a short story written by renowned Indian author R. K. Narayan known for his simple yet powerful storytelling centered around the fictional town of Malgudi. The story revolves around a young schoolboy and a home tutor who uses harsh punishments to discipline him. Set in a middle-class Indian household, the narrative explores themes such as the flaws in the education system, the misuse of authority, child psychology, and the moral consequences of violence. Through subtle humor and keen observation, Narayan sheds light on the complex relationship between fear, learning, and the responsibilities of teachers and adults toward children.

Movie review - Sitare Zameen Par

"हर बच्चा अपने आप में खास होता है, बस उसे सही मार्गदर्शन की ज़रूरत होती है"

💠 Here I am enclosing few photos of movie"Sitare Zameen Par" based on crime and punishment with the classmates: 

🔷 About the Movie 

Sitare Zameen Par is a Hindi-language film directed by and starring Aamir Khan, and serves as a spiritual sequel to his acclaimed 2007 film Taare Zameen Par. While the original film focused on the struggles of a single child with dyslexia, Sitare Zameen Par expands the narrative to focus on a group of children with special needs, particularly those dealing with emotional and behavioral challenges.

In this new story, Aamir Khan plays a passionate and empathetic coach or mentor who works with children involved in minor criminal activities or school indiscipline. Rather than punishing them, he introduces them to sports and teamwork as tools of reformation and self-discovery. The film draws inspiration from themes of crime and punishment, not in a harsh legal sense, but through a lens of rehabilitation, empathy, and inclusion.

Blending emotion, humor, and inspiration, Sitare Zameen Par raises awareness about:

Mental health and behavioral issues in children

The flaws in punitive disciplinary systems

The power of mentorship, compassion, and second chances

The film delivers a strong social message: children who go astray are not criminals—they are stars waiting to be guided, not punished. With the right support, love, and direction, they too can shine.

✨ "Sitare Zameen Par" – A Journey Into the Heart of Education

After reading R. K. Narayan’s insightful short story that reflects on the realities of the education system, the pressure of parental expectations, and the responsibility of teachers, I had the opportunity to watch the movie Sitare Zameen Par in the theatre. This film not only echoed the concerns raised in Narayan’s work but also delivered an emotional and thought-provoking experience about the true meaning of learning, childhood, and human connection.

1. How does the movie portray the education system?

Sitare Zameen Par presents a powerful and honest critique of the modern education system. It shows how the system often emphasizes marks, discipline, and competition over creativity, emotional intelligence, and individuality. The film highlights how students are expected to perform according to a rigid standard, without considering their unique talents or challenges.

In the movie, children are seen struggling not because they lack potential, but because the system fails to recognize their different learning needs. Classrooms are portrayed as places of pressure rather than exploration. This portrayal is similar to what we see in R. K. Narayan’s story, where children are burdened by unrealistic expectations and are not allowed the space to grow at their own pace.

2. What message does the movie give about the role of teachers and parents?

One of the strongest themes in Sitare Zameen Par is the deep impact that teachers and parents have on a child’s life. The movie reminds us that children are not machines designed to produce perfect results—they are human beings with feelings, dreams, and struggles.

The film shows that many parents push their children to succeed based on comparison with others or their own unfulfilled desires. In doing so, they often fail to listen to what their child truly wants or needs. Similarly, some teachers are shown as indifferent, treating children as just roll numbers instead of individuals.

However, the film also introduces us to caring educators who believe in their students, guide them with patience, and help them discover their hidden talents. These characters remind us of what true teaching is a process of understanding, encouragement, and support.

3. How does it compare with R. K. Narayan’s short story?

R. K. Narayan’s short story portrays the traditional education system as one that is rigid and dismissive of the child’s inner world. Children are not seen as individuals with dreams or feelings; instead, they are expected to conform and perform. The adults in the story often fail to understand the silent suffering of children who are not able to meet expectations.

Sitare Zameen Par reflects these very ideas through its modern narrative. Both the story and the film show how lack of understanding from parents and teachers can harm a child’s confidence and development. However, while Narayan’s story ends on a more neutral or tragic note, Sitare Zameen Par offers a ray of hope. It introduces characters who challenge the system and bring positive change in a child’s life. The film, therefore, takes the conversation forward by not just highlighting the problem, but also showing how empathy and effort can make a difference.

4. What did I feel or learn after watching the movie?

Watching Sitare Zameen Par was an emotional experience. I felt sadness for the children who are misunderstood, but also hope because the movie shows that change is possible. It taught me that success should not be defined only by marks or prizes. Each child is unique, and every one of them shines in their own way like stars on earth.

I learned that as a society, we need to listen more and judge less. We need to support children with kindness and believe in their potential. A teacher or parent who understands a child’s struggles can transform their life completely.

✨ Conclusion: Let the Stars Shine

Sitare Zameen Par is a reminder that children are like stars on earth each one glowing with their own light. But too often, the pressure of education and expectations hides that light. Just like R. K. Narayan’s story, the movie urges us to reflect on how we treat children and what we define as success.

The film asks us to rethink education not as a race to the top, but as a journey of discovery and growth. It is a call to all teachers, parents, and society: Look closely. Listen deeply. Every child has a star within they just need someone to believe in them.

Thank you.

Be learners!!